Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Which econo-car would you buy?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Which econo-car would you buy?

    Alright, one of my buddies that has an S2000 recently bought a Yaris liftback as a daily driver, and I was curious about why he didn't stick with the Honda family and get a Fit. So my question is, if you were going to buy an econocar, which would it be?
    P.S.: All the specs are for the cheapest models (hatchback versions), with manual transmissions.

    Chevy Aveo (4-dr hatch)
    MSRP: $10,560 (Chevy claims lowest-priced car in the US, but it seems the Accent is cheaper, unless there's something funny with destination charges or something)
    1.6L (no variable valve timing), 6500 rpm redline
    103 hp @ 5800 rpm
    107 ft-lbs @ 3600 rpm
    curb weight: 2,343 lbs.
    EPA mileage: 27/37

    Honda Fit (4-dr hatch)
    MSRP: $13,850
    1.5L with VTEC, 6500 rpm redline
    109 hp @ 5800 rpm
    105 ft-lbs @ 4800 rpm
    curb weight: 2,432 lbs.
    EPA mileage: 33/38

    Hyundai Accent GS (2-dr hatch, sedan is almost the same as Kia Rio)
    MSRP: $10,415
    1.6L with CVVT valve timing, 6,500 rpm redline
    110 hp @ 6000 rpm
    106 ft-lbs @ 4500 rpm
    curb weight: 2,467 lbs.
    EPA mileage: 32/35

    Nissan Versa 1.8S (4-dr hatch)
    MSRP: $12,550
    1.8L with CVTCS (continously variable valve timing control system), 6500 rpm redline
    122 hp @ 5200 rpm
    127 ft-lbs @ 4800 rpm
    curb weight: 2,722 lbs.
    EPA mileage: 30/34

    Toyota Yaris (2-dr hatch)
    MSRP: $11,150 (liftback)
    1.5L with VVT-i, 6500 rpm redline
    106 hp @ 6000 rpm
    103 ft-lbs @ 4200 rpm
    curb weight: 2,290 lbs.
    EPA mileage: 34/40

    Note: I was going to put the Suzuki Reno in here, but it has a 2.0L engine, and therefore gets an EPA mileage of 20/28, so I decided against it. Also, it's almost as pricey as the Fit (MSRP = $13,299). I also considered the Dodge Caliber, but it's MSRP is $14,935, and it's classified as a compact car. Finally, I thought about the Scion xA and xB, but I figured the Yaris has Toyota covered, plus, the xB is over $16,000.
    43
    Chevy Aveo
    0.00%
    0
    Honda Fit
    72.09%
    31
    Hyundai Accent
    0.00%
    0
    Nissan Versa
    2.33%
    1
    Toyota Yaris
    18.60%
    8
    Other (please specify)
    6.98%
    3

    #2
    Honda Fit buddy....gotta stay with in the family.
    accordtypeR aka Seve aka The Godfather.


    My Old Baby
    ....................My New Baby
    SOLD TO
    ..grumpy93, iceplaya123, slr_theking, tn_accords

    Comment


      #3
      I would get the Fit.

      The Yaris does seem tempting though, with it's better estimated gas mileage. The Fit is more practical

      Members Ride Thread

      Comment


        #4
        The Fit looks horrible

        SOLD!!
        Boosted H22
        375whp 298 ft/lbs at 15psi

        MEMBERS RIDE THREAD<<<CLICK FOR VIDS AND COOL PICS

        Comment


          #5
          The versa or the Fit, or the accord hybrid..
          H22 Prelude VTEC 92-96 200 161 10.6:1 87 90 DOHC VTEC 2157 JDM

          190.3whp 155 wtq - with bolt ons, and a dc header

          ET=14.457 @ 94mph w/ 2.173 60Fter

          Comment


            #6
            haha honda fit all day every day

            Comment


              #7
              Fit + k20 = win.

              Comment


                #8
                Honda fit, everything I see in magazines make them sound really cool. Apparently quicker than one would imagine! I'd want paddle shifters though!

                Oh yeah, honda reliability ftw!

                Yaris on rims looks good though...
                Click for my ride thread.

                Comment


                  #9
                  I like the Fit... but frankly, its not as unique as the xB.

                  Of course, that unique-ness is probably why a lot of people hate the xB, but personally, I'd take the xB.

                  EDIT: just to make it clear, of the cars the original poster listed, I'd take the Fit.
                  Last edited by TheNextEpisode; 05-25-2007, 12:24 AM.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Yaris. Same motor as the xb and very easy to make a turbo kit for the xb fit. although i agree the K20 in the Fit is nice, to buy a car and perform a motor swap instantly is kinda out of my realm of logical reasoning. The yaris hatch is sexy to me, although i really wish they woulda brought over the 4-dr (JDM Vitz):




                    CB7tuner.com Appearance Specialist - PM me with any bodywork questions

                    Comment


                      #11
                      That is a good looking yaris, my decision is swaying....ehhh urgghhh

                      on the stairs, she grabs my arm, says whats up,
                      where you been, is something wrong?
                      i try to just smile, and say everything’s fine.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        the fit then the yaris. the versa weighs alot for a eco-car

                        Comment


                          #13
                          too bad US don't have the "4-dr (JDM Vitz)"...
                          but i'll take the "Yaris"..
                          don't care about swap..
                          if swap, i believe it will take MORE GAS..
                          i'm a Honda guy but when it come to cars, i'll say toyota..NOT TO BE MEAN TO ALL CB7..After all i do own alot and i mean ALOTS of CB in the past..

                          ...........AE86-GTS: SOLD.................................................. ........CB7-DX: SOLD

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Fit here.

                            I choose that not becuse it is a honda and have like the best reliabllty there is. But man the tests have proven it drives like a go Kart. Also the interior looks better than most high priced cars. So Fit to win!
                            1991 White Accord LX 5-speed aka Lil' Red

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Go with the FIT, my mom has one and damn great MPG and powa for the buck.

                              Big 16g Turbo/H23 Head Swap/TSX Projectors

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X